
Clause 4 of Part Two of Article 90 of the Law of Ukraine “On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges” provides for the regular assessment of judges by public associations through an independent assessment of judges’ performance during court hearings.
To participate in regular assessment, the head of a public association must submit the following documents to the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine:
- An application to participate in regular assessment;
- A copy of the public association’s charter;
- An extract from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities and Individual Entrepreneurs;
- A biographical statement of the head of the public association;
- Documents concerning the public association’s sources of funding;
- A list of persons proposed to participate in the assessment;
- A biographical statement with a photograph for each person proposed to participate in the assessment;
- Applications from the persons proposed to participate in the assessment;
- Certificates confirming completion of the National School of Judges of Ukraine’s course on the regular assessment of judges by representatives of public associations, issued to the persons proposed to participate in the assessment;
- An extract from the information and analytical system “Records of Criminal Prosecution and Criminal Convictions” for each person proposed to participate in the assessment, excluding information on their date of birth.
The following representatives of public associations may not evaluate judges’ performance:
- Persons declared by a court to lack legal capacity or to have limited legal capacity;
- Persons with a criminal conviction that has not been expunged or otherwise removed in accordance with the procedure established by law;
- Serving judges, prosecutors, practising advocates and investigators;
- Members of the Parliament of Ukraine; members of regional councils, Kyiv and Sevastopol city councils, district councils, district councils within cities, city councils, village councils and settlement councils.
Public associations may not conduct regular assessments of judges if they have carried out or currently carry out their activities with international technical assistance provided by public authorities, local self-government bodies, institutions, organisations or enterprises of a country recognised by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine as an aggressor state, or if they have received funding from such entities or persons affiliated with them.
A person participating in regular assessment may not represent two or more public associations.
Documents must be submitted electronically.
Scanned copies of documents must meet the following requirements:
- Documents must be in PDF format;
- Each document must be saved as a separate file;
- Each copy must be made from the original document;
- Each copy must be of sufficient quality, legible, and reproduce